Silent Invasion: China’s influence in Australia by Clive Hamilton

Should we be worried?

I recently read this book, against the background of China’s increasing trade war with Australia.  Is Mr Hamilton right, I wondered?  How concerned should we be?

As I read, I am conscious of concerns about foreign ownership of assets within Australia, about the extent of Chinese influence and about political donations.  But is China the enemy?  Or should Australia be re-evaluating foreign ownership rules and tightening political donation rules more generally?

I’m torn.  Many point to human rights abuses in China. True.  But if they were consistent, they would also identify human rights abuses in other countries including Australia and the USA.  There are times when the various forms of representative democracy practiced across the western world seem just as flawed as many claim that the Chinese government is. 

While I think this book is worth reading and I share some of Mr Hamilton’s concerns, I don’t agree that China is Australia’s enemy.  I also feel frustrated when people point to China’s influence in our region.  Many of the countries China is aiding are countries that we would once have provided more aid to.  Should China be condemned for meeting a need that we have ignored?  Sigh.

Yes, I am sure that not all Chinese influence is benign, any more than I am convinced that American influence is.  I am concerned though that much of the reaction against Chinese influence is a reaction against a world which (for the first time in our lifetimes) is looking beyond Europe and the USA to Asia as a source of growing economic power and influence.  I think that many of us find this unsettling.

We need to engage more with China, not less.  And, in all our foreign relationships, we need to be less naïve. Not all interests are benign, common, or shared, but neither are they all exclusive or malign. Yes, I see shades of grey.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


3 thoughts on “Silent Invasion: China’s influence in Australia by Clive Hamilton

  1. I have this book but haven’t read it yet, and having read a number of Australian Foreign Affairs journals on this very topic, I am wondering whether to bother.
    Because I agree with everything you say…

    Liked by 1 person

  2. It might be worth skimming a couple of chapters, but only if you have time. I agree with some of what Clive Hamilton says but I really think we need to move ahead with China. Yes, we need to work out some rules about foreign ownership (by any country, not just China). But I refuse to see China as a demon…

    Liked by 1 person

  3. There was an interesting article in The Saturday Paper recently that also said that we need to move ahead with China. However, it did assess that China is trying to make an example of Australia and argued that we need to remodel our relationship based on one in which we don’t trust each other (than one in which we do.) It noted that other countries are good models for this – like Poland and Russia. It made sense to me.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s