The Wizardry of Jewish Women by Gillian Polack

For some reason, doesn’t like my review, and have told me:
‘Your review of The Wizardry of Jewish Women could not be posted to Amazon’

‘Your review could not be posted.

Thanks for submitting a customer review on Amazon. Your review could not be posted to the website in its current form. While we appreciate your time and comments, reviews must adhere to the following guidelines: ‘

I have no idea which part of my review offends Amazon’s sensibilities.  Do you?

Anyway, here’s the review:

The Wizardry of Jewish Women by Gillian Polack

‘This book is about shadows.  The shadow of the past on our past.’

Meet Rhonda.  Meet Judith, and her sister Belinda.  And as you gradually become familiar with their lives, their loves, their fears and their pasts, you’ll find yourself wondering what the future holds.  For each of them, and for those who matter to them.

While each of these women thinks they want an ordinary, uncomplicated life, it’s never going to be that easy.  Why?  Well, apart from the fact that the past has its own impact, there are the shoals of relationships to be negotiated.  And there is magic as well.  Judith and Belinda have a family mystery to explore: just who is this great-grandmother that non-one talks about?  Judith’s past includes wonderful children.  Can she ever move out from under the shadow cast by family violence?  And Rhonda?  Free-lance work through an agency may have its benefits, but her manager is not one of them.

In Rhonda, Judith and Belinda, Ms Polack has created three quite different women.  Their lives are separate, although they intersect and overlap.  For me, Rhonda was the most intriguing character.  I found myself, in a quite motherly way, concerned about some of her choices and hoping that things would work out.  Judith held my attention as well: her wonderful children Nick and Zöe, her lemon tree, her interest in magic.  While I don’t care in the least about pink tutus (and I may or may not believe in magic), there is a certain unicorn that I’d like to meet.

‘It’s very humiliating to be laughed at by a lemon tree.’

I enjoyed this novel, with its gentle reminders of the complexities of life.  I was reminded too, and less happily, of the horrors of the Canberra bushfires in 2003 and of the impact of violence on people and communities.  Ms Polack has written a novel in which well-developed characters grapple (sometimes successfully) with the kinds of issues many of us are familiar with.  Either through our own direct experience, or the experiences of friends and family members.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith

#AWW 2016



2 thoughts on “The Wizardry of Jewish Women by Gillian Polack

  1. Not a clue – unless the words horrors and violence automatically trigger something. No human would stop this review. You could change the possibly offending section and post again – or remove an entire paragraph at a time to see which one they didn’t like. Odd.


  2. I could do this Alicia, but I won’t. If I could eMail a human at Amazon and get advice, I would. But life’s too short to try to second guess them. I’ve had a couple of reviews that I’ve needed to edit to fit within their guidelines, and it is usually obvious what they want changed. But not this time, and not for the last book I reviewed by this particular author either. I’ll let it go.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s